Need Help/Opinions Choosing a Gun??

[Hopedale Hustler]

Looking to add a new addition to the cabinet...i've been shooting my xtrema the past 2 seasons or so...now that its that time of the year again im ready and looking for something new...preferably a pump...my xtrema is just getting wore out i believe and is starting to have more and more problems....ive always been a pump fan so im goin back to one...i have narrowed it down to 4 to choose from...first being a 870 express super mag...i already know all about this gun got two regular 870's i know its reliable but i want something different i think....the others are the 887 nitro mag....the stoeger p350 pump or the benelli nova......form wat i can tell the p350 and nova are really the same gun just made by sister companies but does the stoeger perform as well as the nova??

also the 887 is a fine gun but i cant seem to figure out if its truly a good buy or not cause of all the mixed reviews....

any help/opinions/advice would be appreciated...also if anyone has one of these guns in good condition for sale let me know....