Need ideas on helping manage deer club

[Nickt87]

What are some rules and repercussions that your club or clubs you have hunted at had?

For instance:
My club is in Mississippi. The clubs requirements are minimum 12" spread or one 15" beam. No penalties for shooting yearlings or spikes. We used to have a penalty of $100 for killing a spike or buck under our requirements, but we got away from that for one reason or the other and have moved to an honor system. The honor system has went down the tube with the same 2-3 guys killing 2-3 spikes or small bucks every year on accident. I have fought to bring back the fines but people are saying that if there is a fine then when people "accidentaly" shoot small deer they will just dump them and not bring them back to the camp. I voted to kick the guys out the club and that went over like a turd in the punch bowl.
This club was the first club in Ms to participate in DMAP back in the 70s and was fairly managed and abundant with deer until the recent tornados that hit Ms and Al a few years back.

What are some of the rules, requirements, and repercussions that yall use?