Anyone want to do me a favor?

[evidrine]

May have found a recoil pad, so thats out of the way. I sanded and re-stained the stock and it came out a very nice color. exactly what I was looking for. Then I sealed it with a high gloss polyurothane. This is was a mistake. I could neary see my dang reflection in the thing. A tad bit way too shiny! I removed all of this and now I have a question. After I re-stain it, again, what should I seal i with. I am tempted to try a semi-gloss polyurothane but want o be certain first. What do you guys think? Will that still be too shiny? I'm not sure if I should try it or not. Is there something else that will work well?